PDA

View Full Version : Help me ID this case please!


kellabeck
08-27-2009, 12:13 PM
I just can't think of the names of the people involved!!

Here are the facts:
A wealthy widow dies on the floor at the base of the sweeping staircase in her mansion in Texas. Her son (3 names and Jr.) claims that it was an accident. Says that he brought/returned a VCR to his mother and they quarreled. He claims that she grabbed this (large) machine from him and rushed up the stairs (in her floor-length pegnoir), he following behind her. Upstairs in the hall they were face-to-face next to the bannister. He claims that she swung the VCR out of his reach and that made her lose her balance and she flew over the bannister and down the stairs.

This was a fascinating trial, broadcast on the old Court TV, one of the first that absorbed me. I recall quite distinctly that the prosecution recreated the hall bannister to prove that his story was ludicrous. And as one of her friends said, "Xxxxxx would never pick up a VCR."

I found the idea of her with a heavy VCR in both hands rushing upstairs in a long gown preposterous. Only someone who has never worn a long dress and walked upstairs -- in other words a man -- would suggest such a thing.

The son, who by the way was accompanied by his daughter, her granddaughter, was tried for murder. The daughter backed up her father. Despite that, he was convicted, as I recall.

The son was an only child, the failed scion of a successful father, Xxxxxx Yyyyy Zzzzzz Jr. probably called "Yyyyyy." The parents were socially prominent. I think the late father was in real estate. The mother thought of herself as Scarlet O'Hara. The son tried going to another town to make his mark but failed and wound up coming home and wanting money from mommy.

That was the motive. Does this sound familiar??

Amy
08-27-2009, 12:41 PM
I know the case you are posting about, have even watched it several times in Forensic Files type of program. But, for the life of me, I can't remember the name, either.

Zeus
08-27-2009, 12:47 PM
I just can't think of the names of the people involved!!

Here are the facts:
A wealthy widow dies on the floor at the base of the sweeping staircase in her mansion in Texas. Her son (3 names and Jr.) claims that it was an accident. Says that he brought/returned a VCR to his mother and they quarreled. He claims that she grabbed this (large) machine from him and rushed up the stairs (in her floor-length pegnoir), he following behind her. Upstairs in the hall they were face-to-face next to the bannister. He claims that she swung the VCR out of his reach and that made her lose her balance and she flew over the bannister and down the stairs.

This was a fascinating trial, broadcast on the old Court TV, one of the first that absorbed me. I recall quite distinctly that the prosecution recreated the hall bannister to prove that his story was ludicrous. And as one of her friends said, "Xxxxxx would never pick up a VCR."

I found the idea of her with a heavy VCR in both hands rushing upstairs in a long gown preposterous. Only someone who has never worn a long dress and walked upstairs -- in other words a man -- would suggest such a thing.

The son, who by the way was accompanied by his daughter, her granddaughter, was tried for murder. The daughter backed up her father. Despite that, he was convicted, as I recall.

The son was an only child, the failed scion of a successful father, Xxxxxx Yyyyy Zzzzzz Jr. probably called "Yyyyyy." The parents were socially prominent. I think the late father was in real estate. The mother thought of herself as Scarlet O'Hara. The son tried going to another town to make his mark but failed and wound up coming home and wanting money from mommy.

That was the motive. Does this sound familiar??

I remember that case! Although, sorry, can't remember the names. IIRC part of the convicting evidence was also that the marks on the banister and wall were in the wrong place for the VCR to have hit if what her son said happened, actually happened.

Jay
08-27-2009, 02:25 PM
I saw it on CTV when it was televised as a trial, I need to rack my brain some, what's left of it that is.


The defense attorney did an excellent job for the client.

There was a live demonstration of pulling a person down a small flight of steps and the person hit thier head.

I also remember, if I have the case correctly, the Prosecutor was sanctioned by the court for "misleading" it.

Roux
08-27-2009, 04:58 PM
I think you are remembering the Bette Lucas murder in Tyler, Texas. It's been featured on many shows, but I looked it up on A&E City Confidential. Season 4, episode 49.

desmom
08-27-2009, 05:15 PM
I think you are remembering the Bette Lucas murder in Tyler, Texas. It's been featured on many shows, but I looked it up on A&E City Confidential. Season 4, episode 49.

http://www.aetv.com/city_confidential/city_episode_guide.jsp?episode=136830

Jay
08-27-2009, 06:09 PM
http://www.aetv.com/city_confidential/city_episode_guide.jsp?episode=136830



Yes, that's it. I checked the defense attorney's profile, and it is him. He was good!!! That was a heck of a trial and Buck defended him with all he had, I was impressed.


http://www.bainfiles.com/Bio/FRFiles.asp

kellabeck
08-27-2009, 06:54 PM
I think you are remembering the Bette Lucas murder in Tyler, Texas. It's been featured on many shows, but I looked it up on A&E City Confidential. Season 4, episode 49.

That's it!!! You win the [imaginary] prize!! I KNEW someone would come through!!

Bette Lucas and her son Steven!

Ironically it's on tv tomorrow!
Aug 28 7:00pm City Confidential: 49 - Tyler: Fallen Rose
Bette Lucas, the most popular philanthropist in the wealthy town of Tyler, Texas, dies mysteriously and her son Steven is accused of murder. After the first trial ends in a hung jury, the second trial is moved to Dallas, where crafty defense attorney Buck Files battles tough district attorney David Dobbs as a nationwide audience watches on TV. Narrated by Paul Winfield.

But not on my cable!